E46Fanatics

E46Fanatics (http://forum.e46fanatics.com/index.php)
-   General E46 Forum (http://forum.e46fanatics.com/forumdisplay.php?f=4)
-   -   Get dents removed or buy the new part? you decide. (http://forum.e46fanatics.com/showthread.php?t=760393)

stevodotorg 04-28-2010 06:30 PM

Get dents removed or buy the new part? you decide.
 
Part number: 41357042323

This got crushed a bit in a hit and run while I was at the gym :( This place here in socal is quoting me $500. That's their wholesale price because my mother works at a stealership that gives them business. All I need is the dents removed from the side corner area.

The part brand new is $266 from Tischer (part no. 41357042323), although I'm not sure if they will ship it for free and I have no idea how much it would be to have painted.

I have buffed out the scratches quite nicely and everything else is fine, luckily I still have the OEM amber corners to use as well, but they won't fit until its all popped out.

If anyone has any other ideas, options, or knows anyone in the socal region that might be of assistance, please feel free to share!

http://stevo.org/public/images/e46sidecrush/ouch.jpg

iansanderson 04-28-2010 10:06 PM

I would always recommend PDR anytime it is possible, but that looks so severe it may not work.

Why not find a fender used, in alpine white? If its OEM with factory paint, it should bolt right up and look good as new!

sam5357 04-28-2010 10:13 PM

That really sucks, was probably some soccer mom in her giant suburban lol. I would say try PDR, but that crease might not come out...... sucks man, would have wrecked my day:bawling:

stevodotorg 04-28-2010 10:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by iansanderson (Post 11673152)
I would always recommend PDR anytime it is possible, but that looks so severe it may not work.

Why not find a fender used, in alpine white? If its OEM with factory paint, it should bolt right up and look good as new!

Any ideas where I might find one? I've been checking the part out forums :(

stevodotorg 04-28-2010 10:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sam5357 (Post 11673189)
That really sucks, was probably some soccer mom in her giant suburban lol. I would say try PDR, but that crease might not come out...... sucks man, would have wrecked my day:bawling:

Totally wrecked my day :(

But I'll update with some new photos later with my real camera and you guys can tell me if it looks like PDR might work.

Alex323Ci 04-28-2010 11:05 PM

$500 for that is pretty good considering the labor too. i'd also buy used if you aren't that picky.
i'd also go to MOBworks paint and body in Orange, they are around the corner from the Pond.
i don't think a PDR would be able to do that. but if so i'd do that.

colinschick 04-28-2010 11:11 PM

i would SO do the body shop route.

in 1 day it could be good as new, compared to shipment time, paint time, yada yada....

plus, thinking about it, $266 + shipping + Paint + tax would be more than $500.....

mr_lee 04-28-2010 11:13 PM

check out car-part.com.. a lot of auto recycling places post it on there. good luck.

NOVAbimmer 04-29-2010 12:07 AM

yeah, it's typically better to fix it on the car than it is to replace the part

even if you find one in alpine white, most likely it will be obviously different, due to differences in paint wear in various areas, and how well the paint was taken care of on the previous car.

Heck, even two brand new cars, same color, will show some variation, just because of the painting process itself. $500 is a great price to fix that.

sonspot 04-29-2010 01:07 AM

junk yard, junk yard, junk yard, auto recycling and ebay, how many times have we said this, grown folks, think for our self and do some work.. am not being rude but seriously asking where to get the part, seriously?

lllSupra 04-29-2010 01:08 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sonspot (Post 11674379)
junk yard, junk yard, junk yard, auto recycling and ebay, how many times have we said this, grown folks, think for our self and do some work.. am not being rude but seriously asking where to get the part, seriously?

How do you have the right to say you aren't being rude :confused:. You are

chet31 04-30-2010 01:24 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by lllSupra (Post 11674387)
How do you have the right to say you aren't being rude :confused:. You are

Who is being rude in this thread?

http://forum.e46fanatics.com/showthr...ighlight=vinyl

golf_234 04-30-2010 01:27 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by stevodotorg (Post 11671824)
Part number: 41357042323

This got crushed a bit in a hit and run while I was at the gym :( This place here in socal is quoting me $500. That's their wholesale price because my mother works at a stealership that gives them business. All I need is the dents removed from the side corner area.

The part brand new is $266 from Tischer (part no. 41357042323), although I'm not sure if they will ship it for free and I have no idea how much it would be to have painted.

I have buffed out the scratches quite nicely and everything else is fine, luckily I still have the OEM amber corners to use as well, but they won't fit until its all popped out.

If anyone has any other ideas, options, or knows anyone in the socal region that might be of assistance, please feel free to share!

http://stevo.org/public/images/e46sidecrush/ouch.jpg

Damn. That is a sexy car too. You would be surprised how well auto body shops can fix that. it will be a bit pricey though. I would honestly lean toward having it fixed. If you look closely you haven't lost the structural integrity of the panel really at all. It can be easily shaped and bondo'd, then painted. Nbd. You should have seen the quarter panel on my mom's mini.. much worse than this and we took it to a really, really good auto body shop and its like new. even the most trained eye could not tell at all. I am estimating about $300-$400 for this job. in this economy you can get it done cheap, esp. down in irvine you have the world at your fingertips. (lived off of jamboree and the 405 last summer). Shop around a lot.

golf_234 04-30-2010 01:28 AM

i have a guy up here in san luis obispo that would fix that for $300. but irvine is quite a ways haha.

golf_234 04-30-2010 01:38 AM

But on second thought if the panel new is $266, it could really go either way. it kind of is all 6's. depends on how deep your pockets are. as it is the fender you have more options than say, a rear quarter panel.

NOVAbimmer 04-30-2010 01:51 AM

the paint will come out a lot better, in general, if all the shop is doing is blending within the front edge of the original panel, rather than spraying an entire fender, at which point they'll want to blend into the door, including de-trim time for it. Replacing the fender, in the end, will cost a lot more than you think.

NOVAbimmer 04-30-2010 01:52 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by golf_234 (Post 11679108)
i have a guy up here in san luis obispo that would fix that for $300. but irvine is quite a ways haha.

and I wouldn't trust a bodyman that gives an estimate based on one mediocre picture only. But that's just me...

golf_234 04-30-2010 02:17 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by NOVAbimmer (Post 11679188)
and I wouldn't trust a bodyman that gives an estimate based on one mediocre picture only. But that's just me...

I agree. That was just my estimate because he is a personal friend and I know he will hook me up. He is the guy for the porsche dealer here. It is fairly easy to see what happened to the panel here though.

golf_234 04-30-2010 02:19 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by NOVAbimmer (Post 11679183)
the paint will come out a lot better, in general, if all the shop is doing is blending within the front edge of the original panel, rather than spraying an entire fender, at which point they'll want to blend into the door, including de-trim time for it. Replacing the fender, in the end, will cost a lot more than you think.

true.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 04:56 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
(c) 1999 - 2011 performanceIX Inc - privacy policy - terms of use