Mine came out great using woodgrain contact paper--shelf lining paper. It was much cheaper than the wrap...by a lot.
I get more comments about it than you'd imagine! At the last meet, everyone just hung around it in awe. I know wood grain wasn't one of your choices, but maybe a compromise...Fern Green Wood Grain Matte.
If you're adamant and it's not too late, then black matte...there was a thread with one and it really looked nice...really nice!
The best choice would be leave it as is...unless, of course, you're under 18, not too handsome, don't like the ladies...then, whatever.
Upcoming NYC dates: Jan 8 and 27. See Facebook for other shows and PM me if you can make one...love to see you there!
Mangofy your E46!