View Single Post
Old 10-23-2012, 07:03 PM   #1
jared_wiesner
Registered User
 
Join Date: Aug 2009
Location: Ontario Canada
Posts: 717
My Ride: 1999 328i
M54/M52tu Cam Timing Tool - Review

I just wanted to post an honest review to thank German Auto Solutions for bringing such a great product to market at a great price. They scratched the E46 communities back by supporting us with this kit. I feel the least I can do in return is tell everyone about it.

*Disclaimer* I am in no way affiliated with German Auto Solutions nor is this an ad for their tools. It is simply an honest review of the timing kit I received from them.

I recently installed Schrick 264/252 cams in my 328i and it certainly is a great change. It just pulls so hard all the way to redline. If you are serious about N/A power in your M54 or M52tu, this is the piece that makes the whole puzzle of mods really perform. The issue with doing this affordably has always been that it is nearly out of reach of anyone who wants to do it themselves. The job is very difficult without guidance. On top of that, the tools necessary to time the new camshafts are typically sold for even more money than the cams cost in the first place. This means many people are forced to take the job to the dealer or an experienced independent shop where costs can get very extreme for the 10+ hours of labour they often charge. The tools needed typically cost upwards of $1000.00 for the official dealer version or around $500.00 for a copy set on Ebay.

German Auto Solutions has solved this with their new timing sets. They offer a personal grade timing kit for those on a budget. Cost for this kit is $100.00
Or, if you want a similar kit to the dealership one, you can get the professional grade kit for $220.00. They sent me both so I could be the guinea pig and give them both a try while timing my cams. Everything I received is in in the picture below



With the personal kit you get everything you see in the picture except for the big red aluminum Vanos timing piece at the bottom and the red tensioner tool on the left (the red hex headed cylinder with the knob screwing through it). Instead of utilizing both of these pieces, GAS has found a way to use the pins you see along the right side of the sprocket diagram to do the same job as both of these items. (the pins are combined with your oem tensioner and vanos unit so that these factory pieces off your engine can be utilized as tools during the timing process) This is how they are able to make the personal kit so affordable.

The Professional kit is made up of everything you see in the picture minus the pins and wrench on the right side of the sprocket diagram.

Not only do you get the kit, but GAS has graciously made and posted DIY instructions for Cam removal, install, and timing in the DIY section on their website. Check it out
www.germanautosolutions.com

Both kits worked next to flawlessly for timing the car as I have also gone and made a DIY for these forums using both kits. Here is the Link to the DIY http://forum.e46fanatics.com/showthread.php?t=952124 The only issue I had was a slight fitment problem due to a strange casting on my schrick cams that didn't allow the rear cam block holding tool to fit properly. It worked great on the OEM cams. (The BMW official tool would have likely also had the same problem with my particular set of Schrick cams) I simply had to grind a small edge of the tool and it worked perfectly. Gary at German Auto Solutions has assured me that all new block holding tools going out will be shaped slightly differently to account for this, so it won't be a problem for anyone else. They really do stand behind their products. I highly recommend the German Auto Solutions timing kits and at the price they are being offered, they really should be the only kit you buy. You can't rent these tools for any cheaper than this.

--- Jared Wiesner
__________________

Last edited by jared_wiesner; 10-24-2012 at 12:47 PM.
jared_wiesner is offline   Reply With Quote
Ads by Google

Guests, get your FREE E46Fanatics.com membership to remove this ad.