| The parts you have pictured are called bulb carriers.
BMW made a change to this part in 03/2003.
The correct one is for your car on the right, Part# 63218 368 762
You just need to get the correct one for the left side. Part# 63218 368 761
Should cost about $11 plus the cost of the correct bulbs.
The one you have pictured on the left is for 03/2003 and later.
Also the one the right has been bent a little on the '8' in the part number.
BMW makes that cut-out a little different so that U.S. bulb carriers fit only amber taillights and Euro carriers fit only clears.
Last edited by UncleDon; 02-20-2009 at 11:31 AM.