Sub Help....Perfects, W6V2, W3V2, Audibahn Amum flat piston????

Here's the deal. I have a PPI PRO 10 and after 5 years the speaker just stopped working last night. I am kind of sad and pissed that i have to spend more $$.

Which speaker would most closley perform to that PPI PRO10 i had?

The cheapest route is the Perfect 10 at 128$.
The JL W6V2 is about 250-280$
The audiobahn Alum flat piston 190$
W3V2 i think i will blow so i am not going consider it.

Anything else i left out that might compete with the PPI?

Which would you get? I know a lot of ppl. LOVE JL but is it worth the extra $$ over the Infinity perfect or something else?

Thanks.